Breakfast Briefing with Marie Thøgersen

Obligations of Non-Belligerent States when Hackers on their Territory Engage in Armed Conflicts

Abstract

One of the most striking aspects of cyberspace is the diffusion of power to the individual. Even a single person can, from the comfort of her/his own home, cause considerable harm to States on the other side of the globe. Since the Russian invasion of Ukraine, both belligerents have successfully deployed novel techniques for the mobilization of individuals in cyberspace. The absence of geographical boundaries in cyberspace triggers important questions regarding the international legal implications for States whose territories are being used for such operations.

To assess how the legal framework stands the test of reality, this presentation examines how international law applies to malicious cyber operations against Russia orchestrated by the IT Army of Ukraine. After a legal characterization of the activities of the IT Army, it scrutinizes the legal norms conferring obligations on territorial States and accounts for the prevailing ambiguities surrounding their application. The principle of due diligence entails an obligation for States to not allow their territories to be used for cyber operations affecting the rights of, and producing serious adverse consequences for, other States.

Special challenges surround the assessment in the context of an armed conflict; the legal consequences of aggression imply important nuances to the notion of ‘contrary to the rights of a State’. Based on an analysis of how the legal framework applies to the activities of the IT Army of Ukraine, it is concluded that for non-belligerents, the legality of refraining from exercising due diligence will often be contingent on contentious legal questions regarding countermeasures and self-defence.

About the Speaker

Marie Thøgersen is a Ph.D. fellow at iCourts, University of Copenhagen, and the Institute for Military Technology, Royal Danish Defence College. Her research explores the international legal implications of the involvement of hackers in armed conflicts.

Click here to register for the event. You will receive the Zoom link when you have registered.

See a list of all the International Law Breakfast Briefings for Spring 2023