Women living with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) today have life expectancies comparable to the general female population, leading to a growing number transitioning through menopause. Recent studies have highlighted healthcare professionals' lack of confidence in managing menopause in women with HIV, raising concerns about potential mismanagement. This review explores and compares information on menopause management in HIV-specific and general guidelines, with the aim of identifying disparities and assessing the comprehensiveness of HIV guidelines. The focus is on three key areas: the diagnosis of menopause, and the assessment and treatment of menopausal symptoms. Additionally, the review evaluates the usage and characteristics of menopausal symptom assessment scales known to have been used in studies involving women living with HIV. In total, five HIV and six general menopause management guidelines, published between 2015 and 2023, were identified through medical databases, internet search engines and searches of reference lists. Five menopausal symptom assessment scales were also included for review. The findings suggest minimal differences in recommendations for treating menopausal symptoms. The HIV guidelines include recommendations on screening for menopause, and some raise awareness of the possibility of drug-to-drug interactions, but none offers guidance on how to diagnose menopause or how to differentiate between HIV-related and menopause-related symptoms. Upon examining the characteristics of the menopausal symptom assessment scales, we found that none had been validated specifically for women with HIV. In conclusion, this review advocates for the development of a comprehensive guideline that addresses all relevant factors in managing menopause in women with HIV.